Frog Blog

Climate Action in 2024 – A Reflection @ 50 Days

A summary of where we’ve been in the first 50 days of this challenge

The Frog will explore The Climate Action Handbook: A Visual Guide to 100 Climate Solutions by Heidi Roop in the first 100 days of 2024

In the first `100 days of 2024 we will explore 100 climate solutions that may “empower you to evaluate, engage, and act” to address on-going climate change as an individual on your terms.

Well begun is half done – Mary Poppins

I am, in fact, half done. And on time. For the last 50 days I have been on a journey to highlight simple actions that an individual can take to make a some impact on mitigating the causes of climate change and anticipating and adapting to the very profound changes that are already underway, with the help of Heidi Roop.

At the halfway point, I thought I would stop and reflect on what I have realized about climate change action in the last 50 days. I am concerned that (if anyone is reading this routinely) that it was all beginning to sound a little preachy. That if you don’t do all of these actions, than somehow your effort is diminished.

That is not the point at all, so I want to remind you that that dominant theme is individual action for its own sake. Wide-scale, effective climate change mitigation and adaptation is a colossal effort that must be driven by governments and corporations. Anyone that argues that only YOU need to change what you are doing to effectively combat climate change (with an overtone of blame) is likely engaging in a cynical disinformation and deflection campaign. ExxonMobil is really good at it.

I am attempting to feed thoughtful individuals who desire to effectively take action for personal reasons. I am hoping that an organized effort will bring clarity on the options available to an individual to take action. I feel strongly that taking action can bring a sense of personal satisfaction in contributing, as an individual, to a larger (and growing) collective action that will have a global impact. This is particularly true for those living in the United States.

I also have been trying point out opportunities (and there will be more in later actions) to reach out and engage with family, friends, and community, and make your voice heard in a wider audience. So take individual action for your own sake. And make your voice heard.

I have fallen into a routine in writing these blog entries. I typically read the section in Heidi’s book during the day, reflect on the action, overlay my own experience, and then sit down and write the blog post in one sitting.

In doing this for 50 days I have had some revelations, which I offer with no particular priority:

The action that I am evidently most passionate about is Day 4: Be Privy to the Politics of Climate Change. That one flowed out of a place of anger and despair. Vote your values. Vote climate change. The stakes are high.

https://www.climatesolutions.org/

The action offering the most profound revelation so far is Day 30: Compost. When a ready process for collecting food scraps was implemented in our county, we took action. We found it satisfying to separate our food scraps, take them to collection point, and then in the spring add a couple of buckets of rich humus to our garden.

Consumers throw food scraps in their trash cans which leads directly to the release of the powerful greenhouse gas methane from landfills. So what was the revelation? I am an organic chemist, and know a lot about decomposition reactions in the anaerobic conditions of a landfill. Until I read Heidi’s book, I never reflected on the danger inherent in this process.

If you want to take one action that will lead to a habit, do everything you can to keep food scraps out of the landfill. Collective action on this, supported and encouraged by local governments, can have a profound impact on climate change mitigation.

Other revelations:

I hope you are finding this series of interest, and would appreciate feedback on what we have discussed so far and if I can make the second half of this journey more compelling or useful for you.

To help out, here are links to all the posts so far:

Overview
Climate Action in 2024
Day 0: Why We Need the 100 Climate Solutions

Starting and Sustaining Your Climate Action Journey
Day 1: Consider Collective and Individual Actions
Day 2: Center Action in Your Strengths and Passions
Day 3: Understand the Disconnect Between Actions and Impact
Day 4: Be Privy to the Politics of Climate Change
Day 5: Beware the Corporate “Anti-Climate” Campaign

Energy Production and Transportation
Day 6: Know What Powers You and Your Home
Day 7: Curb the Cost of Renewable Energy
Day 8: Support Solar and Other Renewables in Your Region
Day 9: Weigh the Impact of Decarbonization
Day 10: Drive and Commute Mindfully
Day 11: Consider Carpooling and Rideshares
Day 12: Buy and Drive an Electric Car
Day 13: Drive Efficiently
Day 14: Be Idle-Free

Travel and Work
Day 15: Fly Less, Fly Economy
Day 16: Vacation Closer to Home
Day 17: Seek Out Eco-Friendly Accommodations
Day 18: Reduce Trash When You Travel
Day 19: Find Alternatives for Work-related Travel
Day 20: Learn More About Climate Financing
Day 21: Divest and Reinvest
Day 22: Telecommute When Possible
Day 23: Seek Out Climate Solutions in the Workplace
Day 24: Reduce the Climate Footprint of the Building Around You
Day 25: Go Green and Cool With Rooftops
Day 26: Consider Climate as Part of Your Career
Day 27: Use Caution With Corporate Climate Commitments

Food and Farming
Day 28: Eat Your Broccoli, and Pass on the Meat
Day 29: Cut Down on Your Food Waste
Day 30: Compost
Day 31: Shop for Your Meals Mindfully
Day 32: Research More Than the Takeout Menu
Day 33: Thoughtfully Opt for Meat Alternatives
Day 34: Switch to Nondairy Alternatives
Day 35: Look Into Eating Locally
Day 36: Enjoy Your Chocolate Responsibly
Day 37: Imbibe With Climate in Mind
Day 38: Get to Know Your Favorite Coffee
Day 39: Support Local, Sustainable Fisheries

Shopping and Consumer Choices
Day 40: Reduce Consumption Through Community Sharing
Day 41: Turn Away From Fast Fashion
Day 42: Weigh Your Diaper Options
Day 43: Ditch the Bottled Water
Day 44: Cut Down on Plastics
Day 45: Avoid Microplastics
Day 46: Make More Thoughtful Online Purchases
Day 47: Slow Down Your Shipping
Day 48: Keep Your Devices Longer and Dispose of Them Properly
Day 49: Shop Your Values
Day 50: Beware Greenwashing

Cheers! And take action!

#rescuethatfrog
Email: rescuethatfrog@gmail.com

5 responses to “Climate Action in 2024 – A Reflection @ 50 Days”

  1. Karen Asmundson Avatar
    Karen Asmundson

    Hi Howard,
    I’ve enjoyed your series. I haven’t found it preachy but instead, concise and fact-based. We all can make small changes that make a big collective difference. I appreciate the metered doses of this information that are easily digested. There’s probably a mixed metaphor somewhere there, but I think you get my drift. How do you eat an elephant? One bite at a time. (I’m not encouraging the eating of elephants.)

    I hope you are well. I’m back in a product engineering role in AASD after working as a production operator in Red Wing for six months. It was a good reminder of how fortunate I am to have the resources and education I do and for the cushy office job I have.

    1. Howard Creel Avatar
      Howard Creel

      Karen! So good to hear from you. I appreciate you taking the time to read the posts. Let’s catch up soon.

  2. Franco Morsino Avatar
    Franco Morsino

    Massive work, and a really engaging one.

    Thanks for your efforts and the clarity on the proposals.

    Compliments again.

    A silent reader

  3. Mark Meyering Avatar

    No need to wait until the end of the concert to applaud a briiiant solo.. Howard, these digests are masterful. Thank you for my daily inspiration. I’ve been selectively forwarding the email to individuals in my circles. I’ve learned (as you have) that what we became comfortable doing & thinking about effective action isn’t always delivering meaningful results. The mantra “Think globally, act locally” was OK at first, but we need to exercise our individual AND community power to drive transformational policy change on the state, national and global levels. By political engagement. By joining the march. By our voices and conversations in all forums, all media, any way possible.

    Final thought (actually midterm at 50 days)… stay strong in your resolve, Howard! I know what it’s like to put time into a well-crafted FB posting that gets zero responses, then post a cute grandkid pic that gets 100 likes. It’s human nature for a reader to reward the easy thing and overthink or take a pass on responding to the hard thing. But here’s the validation: the hard post is the one that gets remembered. And will later come up in real life conversations with the reader.. driving a serious discussion and action. My point: don’t worry about “likes” or anything else. Keep casting your bread out on the water, plant your seeds. Good things will happen.

    My thanks and my best.

    1. Howard Creel Avatar
      Howard Creel

      Thank you for the support and kind words, Mark. I appreciate it.

Climate Action Day 51 – Consider Where You Make Your Home

Actions Around the Home

The Frog will explore The Climate Action Handbook: A Visual Guide to 100 Climate Solutions by Heidi Roop in the first 100 days of 2024

In the first `100 days of 2024 we will explore 100 climate solutions that may “empower you to evaluate, engage, and act” to address on-going climate change as an individual on your terms.

You may be planning where you are going to retire or move to next for a job or to be closer to family. You should consider this carefully. For instance, I had a colleague you decided to retire with his wife to Florida near the coast. They are relatively young and could live 20 or 30 years in their new home. Increased likelihood and intensity of hurricanes aside, I hope they consulted NOAA’s Sea Level Rise viewer when they made their decision on where to invest in retirement properties. Knowing his politics, unlikely.

Enjoy visiting Key West, Florida? Better enjoy it while it is above water.

To paraphrase Heidi, wherever you go, something you care about is at risk from climate change. If you are moving, you do research on the area on what is important to you, cost of living, housing prices, quality of schools and healthcare, etc. Presumably the possibility of catastrophic loss for your family and your possessions would be something you would consider as well. As the impact of weather events intensify with on-going global warming, a given area’s sensitivity to sea level rise, flooding, wildfires and drought should increasingly become critical data informing your decisions.

“In 2021, there were twenty billion-dollar weather and climate disasters in the United States, causing $`152.6 billion in damage”

Heidi Roop

If you don’t consider it, the insurance companies surely are. Coastal areas in the US are home to 42% of the population in the US. With the increased risks for people, habitats, infrastructure, etc., insurance companies are increasing the cost of policies or dropping coverage altogether. The National Flood Insurance Program, run by FEMA, ostensibly provides subsidized flood insurance to policyholders living in flood-prone regions. But it is increasingly less likely to be able to pay claims in years with catastrophic losses.

It is idyllic to live along a river until the climate change intensified torrential rains come and it isn’t.

Minnesota is not a bad place to live, as we are generally unaffected by earthquakes, and hurricanes. We do have the occasional tornado, and blizzard, I suppose and you learn to live with that. With climate change, we are going to be warmer, wetter, and more prone to damaging rain events, which means flooding is going to be a bigger problem. Still, even with all that, it might be a good place to retire.

Useful decision making tools include FEMA’s Flood Maps, NOAA’s Sea Level Rise viewer, and the US Forest Service’s Wildfire Risk to Communities maps.

Next Up: Climate Action in 2024 – Day 52: Check Your Insurance Policy

#rescuethatfrog
Email: rescuethatfrog@gmail.com

Climate Action Day 50 – Beware Greenwashing

Shopping and Consumer Choices

The Frog will explore The Climate Action Handbook: A Visual Guide to 100 Climate Solutions by Heidi Roop in the first 100 days of 2024

In the first `100 days of 2024 we will explore 100 climate solutions that may “empower you to evaluate, engage, and act” to address on-going climate change as an individual on your terms.

Greenwashing – “the act or practice of making a product, policy, activity, etc. appear to be more environmentally friendly or less environmentally damaging than it really is”. As in hopelessness also leaves people more vulnerable to greenwashing  campaigns by fossil fuel companies – Matt Simon, WIRED, 27 Dec. 2023.

Hopelessness or hopefulness? I would like to be encouraged by a 2021 published marketing study shows that 34 percent of consumers globally are willing to pay more for sustainable goods and 63 percent report taking action to be more sustainable in their consumer behavior.

Cynically you can conclude that marketing departments read this study and got to work aligning current or new products to make sure they capture the sustainably conscious demographic. Akepa, an agency focused on sustainable marketing provided a in-depth exploration of examples of greenwashing – check out the claims made by some of your favorite companies including Delta, Hefty, Keurig, and IKEA.

https://thesustainableagency.com/blog/greenwashing-examples/

As in all interactions with advertising and social media, dial up your skepticism. Look out for (and do business with) the companies that are working for real change including reducing packaging, eliminating toxic chemicals, decarbonizing their manufacturing processes and supply chain (Scope 3 emissions), and design for repair, reuse, and recycling of their products.

EcoWatch is a useful resource to support your skepticism and combat greenwashing as you take action. They suggest some simple habits to aid you in the choices you make:

  • Ignore the hype – read past the marketing rhetoric. Look for simple language and claims that are backed up with testing and reporting.
  • Check for clarity – scrutinize claims; often they only refer to the packaging or a part of the product
  • Look for certifications – reputable companies will seek third-party endorsements like B Corp, USDA organic or fair trade certification

Here’s your homework for this week. Spot all the ways ExxonMobil is greenwashing the hell out of everyone in this recent ad:

Next Up: Climate Action in 2024 – Day 51: Consider Where You Make Your Home

#rescuethatfrog
Email: rescuethatfrog@gmail.com

Climate Action Day 49 – Shop Your Values

Shopping and Consumer Choices

The Frog will explore The Climate Action Handbook: A Visual Guide to 100 Climate Solutions by Heidi Roop in the first 100 days of 2024

In the first `100 days of 2024 we will explore 100 climate solutions that may “empower you to evaluate, engage, and act” to address on-going climate change as an individual on your terms.

We have gotten used to convenience in how we make our purchases. We may rationalize that we are living our complicated lives in complicated times and we should not have to labor to purchase the items we need. One-click shopping has been made so easy and convenient, that we lose sight of the impact we are having on the climate and our environment.

“… shopping at places that reflect our values – whether they be social, environmental, political or all of the above – can have a direct and positive impact on us”

Heidi Roop

But we should take the time to research and make choices that can make a change. There are big differences in the outlook and approach companies are taking to addressing the issues you care about. The good news is that there is an organization “dedicated to making social and environmental data available to consumers who wish to utilize their dollars as votes in order to help build a better world”.

The Better World Shopping Guide is a comprehensive guide to choosing the companies that fit your values and amplifying their actions through you directing your purchases to them. By researching reliable databases, the Better World Shopping Guide provides a grade for companies based on these five critical criteria:

https://betterworldshopper.org/

You can search the companies of interest to you and make a decision on whether they are worthy of your business. You can also buy the Better World Shopping Guide as a handy pocketbook or app or the more comprehensive Better World Handbook for a more comprehensive approach.

The Better World Shopping guide is one of the resources that can aid your own research as you make consumer choices if you are looking to choose reputable and ethical companies and minimize the carbon footprint of your purchases. It is also a good reference guide if you suspect that a company is engaging in greenwashing, the subject of our Day 50 Action!

Next Up: Climate Action in 2024 – Day 50: Beware Greenwashing

#rescuethatfrog
Email: rescuethatfrog@gmail.com

Climate Action Day 48 – Keep Your Devices Longer and Dispose of Them Properly

Shopping and Consumer Choices

The Frog will explore The Climate Action Handbook: A Visual Guide to 100 Climate Solutions by Heidi Roop in the first 100 days of 2024

In the first `100 days of 2024 we will explore 100 climate solutions that may “empower you to evaluate, engage, and act” to address on-going climate change as an individual on your terms.

How many old cellphones do you have stashed away? It turns out, globally only 1% of smartphones are recycled. The environmental cost of e-waste is staggering as we manufacture, use, and discard them. In 2019, for instance, 53.6 million metric tons of e-waste with $57 billion worth of precious metals wasted in reckless disposal practices.

The evolution of the cellphone to the smartphone. You probably have these lying around the house somewhere. Factory reset then recycle them!

Smartphone manufacturing is a major source of carbon emissions, as much as 125 million metric tons of CO2e annually. The production processes for smartphones is the bulk of the emissions with only 16% of the emissions coming from actual usage. The accumulation of e-waste at the end of life has impacts beyond the climate. It is environmental justice issue in that disadvantaged communities and developing nations are increasingly the victim of the waste we generate.

https://eridirect.com/blog/2017/06/why-is-e-waste-being-shipped-to-developing-countries/

Historically the societal preference is to throw away the old and buy the new. Recycling e-waste is a challenge and manufacturers are not driven to provide recycled content in new device (see what Apple does). It is likely that you live in an enlightened community and you are encouraged to recycle your electronics. The key driver that while the amount is small, electronic waste in landfills represents 70% of the overall toxic chemicals that are present.

If you are a conscientious recycler of your electronics, you may feel satisfied as you drive away after dropping your devices at your local recycling center. What happens next, though? It could be that your device gets scrapped and shipped to another country, to avoid the high labor cost and environmental protections that we enjoy in the US. It often ends up in toxic dumps where workers, at great peril, salvage some valuable components for pennies per pound.

If you want some confidence that your discarded electronics will not be shipped to Pakistan, consider recycling them with Ridwell, who works with responsible recyclers that minimize the environmental impact of the process.

For your personal actions, given the climate cost of manufacturing these devices, keeping them longer is your best way to have an impact. And be motivated to responsibly recycle them.

And keep in mind that using the device has a hidden climate cost as “every text, email, funny meme, or online purchase we make requires a server and data center, which are incredibly energy intensive”. Check out the climate challenge of data centers and storage, and why it is a major problem for the US.

Next Up: Climate Action in 2024 – Day 49: Shop Your Values

#rescuethatfrog
Email: rescuethatfrog@gmail.com

Climate Action Day 47 – Slow Down Your Shipping

Shopping and Consumer Choices

The Frog will explore The Climate Action Handbook: A Visual Guide to 100 Climate Solutions by Heidi Roop in the first 100 days of 2024

In the first `100 days of 2024 we will explore 100 climate solutions that may “empower you to evaluate, engage, and act” to address on-going climate change as an individual on your terms.

Continuing our discussion of e-commerce from Day 46 let’s consider the wisdom of drones delivering our packages. Seriously. It is easy to dismiss that potential future out of hand, but the issue lies with the last mile. Companies can plan for and control the emissions for the shipment of goods from sources to distribution warehouses, but getting the packages to individual homes is usually has the biggest impact on the carbon footprint of a given transaction.

Organized and implemented well, routine drone delivery is not a bad option, short of using a fleet of bicycle couriers (easier to do in dense population centers). According to research from Carnegie-Mellon, for smaller packages with high relative value, drones are a legitimate energy efficiency choice, with only e-cargo bicycles as a better alternative (for small package delivery).

https://engineering.cmu.edu/news-events/news/2022/09/16-last-mile-drones.html

For your current e-commerce habits, you can positively impact the last-mile emissions of your purchases by adopting important habits. The most important is choosing the timing of your deliveries. The short delivery options (one-day to one-hour) constrain the delivery companies in such a way that they trade off energy efficiency and thus emissions to meet the consumer-imposed deadline. Short delivery windows can result in as much as a 180% increase in emissions associated with the delivery.

Heidi suggests several habits to adopt, depending on where e-commerce fits in your daily life. These include:

  • Use the “auto-ship” function for recurring purchases of staple goods that you use routinely. This give full autonomy to the shipper to optimize the delivery to reduce their cost and emissions.
  • Be thoughtful and explore slower and combined shipping options.
  • Resist the urge to buy more than what you need from an online retailer if you are not sure exactly what you want (relying on returns, which amplify the emissions). This is especially true for clothing and shoes, which may better be purchased in a brick and mortar store.
  • As always, choose your companies with a little research so that they align with your values. Many retailers are not interested in sustainability and will not do what it takes to reduce the climate impact of your purchases.

“With a little planning and forethought, we can save money and reduce the climate impact of our online purchases”

Heid Roop

Next Up: Climate Action in 2024 – Day 48: Keep Your Devices Longer and Dispose of Them Properly

#rescuethatfrog
Email: rescuethatfrog@gmail.com

Climate Action Day 46 – Make More Thoughtful Online Purchases

Shopping and Consumer Choices

The Frog will explore The Climate Action Handbook: A Visual Guide to 100 Climate Solutions by Heidi Roop in the first 100 days of 2024

In the first `100 days of 2024 we will explore 100 climate solutions that may “empower you to evaluate, engage, and act” to address on-going climate change as an individual on your terms.

If you have not reflected on it, you may have mixed feelings using a one click option from the comfort of your home to order that item you may feel you need right now. The order is made simply, your credit card is charged, you wait a bit, a truck pulls up, and someone gets out and places a box at your door.

As a society, we do this a lot. Pause a minute and estimate how many packages are delivered in the US every year. Highlight here for the answer –> 165 billion packages shipped every year. That’s 500 packages per person.

Is it more efficient for you to grab your keys, drive to the store, and buy the item you bought online? Maybe not. Amazon uses an algorithm called Condor (Customer Order and Network Density Optimizer) to optimize the routes and schedules for their drivers that helps them save miles, money, and emissions.

“Improved coordination and efficiency could reduce up to 84 percent of emissions from e-commerce transportation!”

Heidi Roop

The environmental impact of e-commerce infrastructure remains a significant social justice issue, though. The warehouses that support the industry are often located close to disadvantage communities, exposing the residents to increased pollution like nitrous oxides, increased traffic and noise. In a report from Mother Jones, José Acosta-Córdova of Little Village Environmental Justice Organization in Chicago laments that “our communities are being sacrificed in the name of economic development.”

Your impact can be programmed into the choices you make on what you order and how you choose to have it delivered. Often 1-day shipping is terrible for the climate, especially if you order items that you can get on your next trip to the grocery store. There is also a tendency to overbuy for convenience, especially clothes and shoes. Consumers order multiple pairs of shoes and clothing items with the intention of returning the ones they don’t want. This return habit for shoes and clothes – with a return rate of 56% – is costly, climate-wise.

To have an impact, be thoughtful, shop online with intention, and consolidate purchases as much as you can.

Next Up: Climate Action in 2024 – Day 47: Make More Thoughtful Online Purchases

#rescuethatfrog
Email: rescuethatfrog@gmail.com

Climate Action Day 45 – Avoid Microplastics

Shopping and Consumer Choices

The Frog will explore The Climate Action Handbook: A Visual Guide to 100 Climate Solutions by Heidi Roop in the first 100 days of 2024

In the first `100 days of 2024 we will explore 100 climate solutions that may “empower you to evaluate, engage, and act” to address on-going climate change as an individual on your terms.

Clothes wear out. Shirts and socks get thinner and “threadbare”. As you drive your car, your tires become progressively bald until you replaced them. Take a minute and reflect. Where do the fibers in your clothes and the rubber in your tires go?

Normal wear and tear of everyday objects results in the formation of microscopic plastic particles and fibers that are referred to as microplastics. On the order of 5 mm and smaller, these tiny bits of rubber, fibers, and plastics accumulate in the environment and represent as dire an existential threat to life on earth as on-going climate change.

About 80% of the microplastics in the environment come from textiles, tires, and dust generated in urban areas. You might have also heard of microbeads, which are microplastic products added to other products such as cosmetics. These have nominally been banned in many countries including the US, but still find their way into products and then into the environment.

Microplastics are found everywhere, including the ocean, sea ice, freshwater, soil wildlife and in increasing concentration in humans. For the first time in 2022, microplastics were found in fresh snow in Antarctica.

It is the global accumulation of microplastics in the ocean that has a serious climate implication. It is estimated that 12 million metric tons of plastic enters the ocean each year. The plastic is broken down into small fragments that can have serious effects on marine ecosystems. For more detail see Microplastics pose risk to ocean plankton, climate, other key Earth systems.

The climate issue is related to the zooplankton that are the basis for the marine food chain. A key ocean process is called the carbon or biological pump. Carbon dioxide is dissolved into the ocean and taken up by the zooplankton. As part of the cycle, the carbon ends up being stored in the deep ocean. Microplastics can reduce feeding rates and fertility and increase mortality of zooplankton, disrupting this carbon pump process. It can also result in increased algae blooms which locally reduces oxygen levels and degrades the overall health of the oceans.

Hugh W. Ducklow , Deborah K. Steinberg and Ken O. Buesseler – https://tos.org/oceanography/article/upper-ocean-carbon-export-and-the-biological-pump

Microplastics may be an intractable problem. How does one clean the large plastic trash from the ocean, let alone filter for plastics on the microscale? Closer to home, your local ecosystem may be impacted by microparticles of rubber from tire wear from your car and your local wastewater treatment system might not be dealing effectively with microfibers from synthetic fabrics that you launder.

Effective actions to take? Individually, consume less, use less plastic, drive less, and consider how you launder you clothes with synthetic fibers. For laundry, Patagonia has some useful suggestions.

Also consider supporting organizations like the Plastic Soup Foundation or the Plastics Pollution Coalition and lending your strong voice to their cause. It will take a focused, dedicated, and sustained effort to address the problem of microplastics in our oceans, in marine life, and in our bodies.

Next Up: Climate Action in 2024 – Day 46: Make More Thoughtful Online Purchases

#rescuethatfrog
Email: rescuethatfrog@gmail.com

Climate Action Day 44 – Cut Down on Plastics

Shopping and Consumer Choices

The Frog will explore The Climate Action Handbook: A Visual Guide to 100 Climate Solutions by Heidi Roop in the first 100 days of 2024

In the first `100 days of 2024 we will explore 100 climate solutions that may “empower you to evaluate, engage, and act” to address on-going climate change as an individual on your terms.

“There’s a great future in plastics”, Mr. McGuire says to Benjamin in the film The Graduate, released in 1967. We are a plastics driven society. They are ubiquitous. From an energy standpoint, you can convince yourself that compared to high energy processes for other materials like glass and aluminum, plastic packaging is an energy efficient alternative. But their versatility and widespread use comes at a cost, in the greenhouse gas emissions from their production, transportation and use, accumulated mass in landfills, and widespread plastics pollution on land and at sea.

Ocean and shore pollution has surprising sources. For instance, 5 million tons of debris was washed into the Pacific Ocean during the Great East Japan Earthquake and tsunami on March 11, 2011. Source.

Plastics are produced from fossil carbon pumped up from storage in the earth in the form of crude oil. The simplest commercial plastic and most widely used is polyethylene, which is very simple, large hydrocarbon molecule that has useful properties for packaging and other commodity uses. If you think in terms of coal plants, the number for plastics production for use is 189. That is, the annual emissions from the production of plastics globally is equivalent to 189 coal plants polluting around the clock.

Without a wholesale change in attitudes on plastics consumption and recycling, those associated emissions will unsustainably increase and the downstream problems of disposal and pollution will only get worse.

What we really must address is plastics packaging, which is what we most encounter in our daily lives. It represents 40% of the plastics production and is most likely to be discarded after a single use, often in the store parking lot or on the side of the road. Most consumers do not stop and reflect on the impact that single-use packaging has on their lives, and their community. When surveyed, 71% of Americans state that they “use fewer single-use plastics to help protect the environment”.

https://www.pewresearch.org/science/2021/05/26/local-impact-of-climate-change-environmental-problems/ps_2021-05-26_climate-and-generations_03-06/

As great deal of trash is treated as “waste-to-energy”, or burned to generate electricity. Often this is done in plants located in disadvantaged communities that cannot escape the chemical pollution and reduced air quality from the plants, even while utilizing the electricity from the source. Waste-to-energy can also be used as a questionable carbon offset that can be used by companies and governments in their calculation of their carbon footprint. Mother Jones is critical of the practice.

It is hard to go plastics free. Recently we informed our local high-end grocery store that they had a choice to source alternative bags to package their fresh baked bread – the ones they supplied inexplicably had a plastic window that rendered them unrecyclable.

Your lifestyle dictates what we can do, and add your voice to society to rapidly establish a circular economy that addresses plastics waste. Review your habits and adopt processes that reduce plastics while maintaining convenience, like keeping reusable shopping bags in your car for your use at the store. Review your county’s recycling policies and adhere to them to reduce the impact on your local recycling sorting center. Consider services like Ridwell, which (for a fee) will help you “sustainably reuse and recycle your stuff”. T

There may indeed be a great future in plastics, a future where their use is limited, circular, and has minimal impact on the environment. The plastics industry is responsible for making this a reality, and may only be motivated by emerging global regulation. As Heidi says “it is critical to encourage the manufacturing industry to accelerate the reduction, recycling, reuse and remanufacturing of plastic and invest in innovations to reduce the climate and environmental impacts of plastic”. Your voice is critical to drive them to act.

Next Up: Climate Action in 2024 – Day 45: Avoid Microplastics

#rescuethatfrog
Email: rescuethatfrog@gmail.com

Climate Action Day 43 – Ditch the Bottled Water

Shopping and Consumer Choices

The Frog will explore The Climate Action Handbook: A Visual Guide to 100 Climate Solutions by Heidi Roop in the first 100 days of 2024

In the first `100 days of 2024 we will explore 100 climate solutions that may “empower you to evaluate, engage, and act” to address on-going climate change as an individual on your terms.

There are plenty of situations where bottled water saves lives, when there is a disaster, for instance, or no ready access to potable water. But bottled water is not a long term solution to addressing water scarcity of quality. The US consumed 15.9 billion gallons of bottled water in 2022 which makes the US the largest global bottled water consumer market.

Given the ready supply of potable tap water in most of the US, we increasingly choose plastic bottles with brands such as Aquafina, Glacéau Smart Water, Dasani, and Poland Spring. We are marketed to relentlessly as callous companies seeking profits try to convince us that their water tastes better or is safer than what comes out of the tap.

Water should be free, but has been turned into a commodity. Pure. Pristine. Natural. 25% of the water bottled in the US comes from municipal water sources – Aquafina and Dasani in particular. To make other claims, the FDA thankfully has regulations for standards of identity. For example, if has more than 250 parts per million of total dissolved solids, you can call it “mineral water”. If you claim it is “spring water” the water has to be sourced from an underground formation which flows naturally to the surface.

FIJI Water is sourced entirely from an artesian aquifer in Viti Levu, an island in the Fiji archipelago. The product is marketed as “Earth’s finest water”. Wow. Refreshing. But Fiji is in the Pacific and it is a long way from there to here. Vox does not like them much. Among other indictments, apparently FIJI water has higher levels of arsenic compared to tap water.

So reach for the Dasani or Aquafina. It may be municipal water that you could otherwise get cheaply, but at least you know it wasn’t on a boat or plane to get it to your local store.

Hold a bottle of water and consider the source. As always we trace the entire supply chain from pumping and processing, manufacturing the bottles, filling and packaging, and transportation. From an energy standpoint and thus climate impact, municipal water from reusable containers is the clear choice. In a review of life cycle analyses it was clear that “tap water always has the best environmental performance, even in the case of high energy-consuming technologies for drinking water treatments”.

“It takes 1000 to 2000 times more energy to produce bottled water that tap water”

Heidi Roop

Oakdale MN provides its citizen a reliable source of clean drinking water at low cost. According to the 2022 water report, there were no violations or adverse events. Oakdale treats the water with additives for disinfection and fluoride to promote strong teeth. Many complain about the flavor, which stems from the disinfection process.

We have a granular activated carbon (GAC) filter in our refrigerator that removes all the additives and trace compounds to deliver a fresh, clean glass of water with little waste, no plastic (except the filter housing), and low expenditure of energy. I am also satisfied with the commitment that my company has made to provide ready sources of filtered municipal water for their employees.

I have adopted habits and invested in infrastructure so that rarely am I forced to drink from a plastic bottle bought from a store. My choice. My lifestyle. For others, convenience seems to be the driving factor for many to choose bottled water. We need voices online and in our communities to help people realize the impact on climate change and plastic pollution. Remember to stay hydrated (preferably from your tap)!

https://www.statista.com/chart/29621/why-people-buy-bottled-water/

Next Up: Climate Action in 2024 – Day 44: Cut Down on Plastic

#rescuethatfrog
Email: rescuethatfrog@gmail.com

One response to “Climate Action Day 43 – Ditch the Bottled Water”

  1. Benjamin Clifton Avatar
    Benjamin Clifton

    Agreed 100%…our family has done “taste tests” comparing our tap water (in Oregon City from the Clackamas River) to the various “gourmet” waters, and our tap water usually comes up on the top or near it.